Best Books Similar to The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches

If Irregular Witches made you fall in love with the idea of found families, this one will completely steal your heart. Imagine a by-the-book caseworker sent to evaluate a home filled with magical children including a gnome, a wyvern, and a boy who just might be the Antichrist. It sounds wild, but the story is deeply tender. Linus, the main character, starts off rigid and lonely, and watching him slowly open up to love, laughter, and belonging feels like wrapping yourself in a blanket on a rainy day. It’s whimsical, heartwarming, and brimming with that “cozy but still magical” atmosphere.

This one mixes folklore, small-town magic, and the everyday lives of women who barter with fairies for little wishes. It’s gentle, a little bittersweet, and packed with the kind of atmosphere that makes you want to light a candle and curl up with it. If you loved the “magic tucked into the ordinary” side of Irregular Witches and looking for books similar to The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches, you’ll adore this.

This is the book everyone talks about when they mention cozy fantasy, and for good reason. Instead of saving kingdoms or battling villains, Viv the orc decides to retire from adventuring and open a coffee shop. The stakes are small -will people like her lattes?- but the emotions are huge. There’s friendship, slow-burn romance, and a gentle reminder that it’s okay to reinvent yourself at any stage of life. If Irregular Witches made you smile because of its warmth and quirky cast, this will feel like coming home.

If Legends & Lattes is about starting fresh, this prequel is about the unexpected connections we make along the way. Young Viv is injured and forced to rest in a sleepy town where she befriends a cranky bookseller, a baker, and a few others who slowly work their way into her heart. It’s like one long hug for book lovers, with plenty of cozy details (the bookshop smells, the quiet companionship) and just enough magic to keep things whimsical.

Atwater has a knack for writing magical stories that are equal parts charming and clever. In Small Miracles, we meet a mischievous fallen angel who shows up in the life of a struggling woman, bringing with him small acts of magic… some good, some questionable. It’s funny, sweet, and filled with the kind of sharp wit that keeps you smiling even as it tugs at your heart. If you loved the humor and tenderness in Irregular Witches, this will absolutely delight you.

If you adored Mandanna’s style in Irregular Witches, her next cozy witchy novel is a must. Here, we follow a witch in her 30s who inherits an old inn full of quirks and secrets. It’s equal parts magical chaos and heartfelt self-discovery, with plenty of family drama, healing, and romance sprinkled in. It carries the same voice you already love: funny, warm, and filled with magical heartbeats that make you wish you could step inside. Don’t forget to check the best books similar to A Witch’s Guide to Magical Innkeeping.

Think of this as cozy fantasy with a bit of spice. Hart is a grumpy marshal patrolling the borders of the afterlife, while Mercy is an undertaker trying to keep her family business afloat. They hate each other… until anonymous letters spark a secret friendship. This book blends romance, humor, and quirky side characters with a magical setting that feels refreshingly original. If you loved the way Irregular Witches balanced magic with relationships, you’ll adore this one.

This one leans more on the historical/mystical side, but it has the same witchy heartbeat. Weyward follows three women across different centuries, all connected by a legacy of magic and resilience. It’s less “cozy cottagecore” and more “witchy empowerment,” but it still carries that same sense of belonging, of discovering your own magic when you need it most. If you’re drawn to the witchcraft element in Irregular Witches, this one will feel like a deeper, more atmospheric echo. Don’t forget to check the best books similar to Weyward!

Here’s something a little mythic. This novel retells the Norse story of Angrboda, a witch who falls in love with Loki. It’s atmospheric, magical, and rich with themes of love, resilience, and motherhood. While it’s more mythic than cozy, the focus on personal magic and emotional strength gives it the same heart as Irregular Witches. Perfect for ones seeking books similar to The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches.

This is for readers who just want more witches, more coziness, and more small-town magic. The story follows a witch named Brynn who reluctantly gets pulled back into using her powers when a death occurs in her aunt’s inn. It’s part mystery, part magical comfort, and the quirky cast of townsfolk gives it a similar “eccentric community” charm that makes Irregular Witches so lovable.

If you don’t mind a graphic novel in the mix, Mooncakes is such a delight. It follows Nova, a young witch who works in her grandmother’s magical bookshop, and Tam, a werewolf who returns to town looking for help. What unfolds is a tender story about family, love, identity, and belonging… all wrapped in gorgeous illustrations that radiate warmth. The book is full of little cozy touches: family dinners, autumn forests, spellbooks, and cups of tea. At the same time, it has that same gentle but powerful reminder found in Irregular Witches: that love and chosen family can be the strongest magic of all. It’s sweet, inclusive, and feels like a hug in illustrated form.

If you loved the idea of witches but wanted something bigger and bolder, this is your book. Harrow writes about three sisters who get caught up in a movement to bring witchcraft back into the world. It’s lush, feminist, and emotionally rich, with prose that feels almost spell-like. While the tone is more dramatic than Irregular Witches, the themes of sisterhood, chosen family, and reclaiming your magic connect beautifully.

A true classic in witchy fiction. This novel (and its prequels) tells the story of the Owens women, cursed in love but gifted in magic. It’s less “cozy fantasy romp” and more “family saga with enchantment,” but it carries the same balance of warmth, humor, and a little bit of heartbreak. If you enjoyed the homey, witch-next-door feeling in Irregular Witches, Hoffman’s world is the perfect next step.

This one shifts into YA territory, but it’s just as charming. We follow Shay, a scholarship student at a magical high school, juggling ambition, friendship, and self-worth. It’s witty, modern, and inclusive, with magic woven into everyday struggles. Readers who liked the lighter, funny parts of Irregular Witches will find that same youthful spark here.

The All Souls Trilogy is a little grander in scope than Irregular Witches. Think history, science, witches, and vampires rolled into one! But at its heart, it’s about love, legacy, and finding where you belong. The Book of Life wraps up the trilogy with lush writing and a magical academic feel. If you want more witch stories that blend romance with a wider world, this will scratch that itch.

While there aren’t witches here, the emotional heart is similar: a lonely outsider suddenly thrust into a new life, slowly building bonds with the people around him. Maia, the half-goblin emperor, is kind, thoughtful, and oh-so easy to root for. The politics are there, but what makes it shine is its warmth and optimism. A perfect pick if you loved the community and gentleness in Irregular Witches.

This book is like a cup of tea for your soul. It’s about a monk and a tea-serving robot wandering through a quiet world, asking questions like “What do people need to feel fulfilled?” It’s slow, thoughtful, and deeply cozy in a philosophical way. If Irregular Witches made you feel good about belonging, this one will make you feel good about simply existing.

Sometimes you just want a rom-com with witches, right? This book delivers exactly that: charm, romance, and just enough spellcraft to keep things sparkling. It’s lighthearted and fun, perfect for when you want that magical feel without heavier themes. Think of it as a Hallmark movie, but with witches. You’ll love it if you are looking for books similar to The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches.

Another Klune gem, this one blends humor, found family, and a touch of afterlife magic. Wallace, a cold lawyer, dies suddenly and finds himself in a teashop between worlds, where he learns about kindness, love, and letting go. It’s bittersweet but incredibly uplifting, very much in the same spirit as Mandanna’s witches, full of love and second chances.

If you enjoyed the quirky, whimsical characters in Irregular Witches, you’ll love this ragtag cast of robots, inventors, and found family dynamics. It’s a reimagining of Pinocchio, but done with Klune’s signature blend of humor, heart, and tenderness. The eccentric companionship will remind you of the lovable chaos in Mandanna’s novel.